I don’t know about you, but I feel every time I make a purchase I am asked if I am a member, do I want to become a member, and before I know it, I am giving my email address over and adding to the hundreds of already unopened emails I receive! Do not get me wrong, there are some loyalty programs I just love but there are many that feel they have been created just to get our details.
So, what makes a great loyalty program and what needs to be considered before introducing one at your store.
- Customer Retention
Loyalty programs can be an effective way to build long-term customer relationships. By offering rewards or discounts based on frequent purchases, customers are incentivised to return to your store, creating a sense of value and appreciation. In a market where customers have numerous options for refuelling, food and convenience, a loyalty program can help ensure your store remains top of mind. - Data Collection and Personalisation
Loyalty programs allow you to collect valuable customer data, which can be used to personalise offers and promotions. Understanding purchasing habits enables you to target your marketing more effectively, whether it is promoting fuel discounts, food and beverage items, or car washes. Tailored marketing increases the likelihood of customer engagement and higher sales. - Increased Spend Per Visit
Customers who are engaged in loyalty programs tend to spend more per visit. By offering rewards that are contingent on reaching specific spending thresholds, you encourage customers to purchase additional items. - Competitive Advantage
In a saturated fuel market, having a loyalty program can give your store an edge over competitors. Many customers are loyal to brands that offer tangible rewards, and a well-structured program can be the deciding factor when choosing between two competing fuel stations.
On the other side, all of this is great but depending on the size of your business there can be a lot that needs consideration.
- Implementation and Maintenance Costs
Setting up a loyalty program requires an investment in technology, infrastructure, and your team. Whether it is a physical card system or a digital app, the costs can add up quickly. Moreover, you will need to continuously maintain, market and update the program, ensuring it remains relevant and appealing to customers. For smaller stores, these costs may outweigh the benefits. - Customer Fatigue
Not all customers are enthusiastic about loyalty programs. Some may feel overwhelmed by the number of programs they already participate in, leading to disengagement. If the rewards are not compelling enough or the program is too complicated to use, customers may abandon it altogether. You need to ensure the program offers clear, tangible benefits that justify the effort required to participate. - Potential for Low ROI
While loyalty programs can increase customer retention, they do not always guarantee higher profits. If the rewards are too generous or the program attracts too many low-spending customers, you might find yourself spending more on rewards than you earn in return. It is crucial to design a program that balances the costs with the potential revenue increase. It is also critical to ensure the rewards are ones that really will incentivise your customers to shop with you more and ultimately spend more money.
If you are considering a loyalty program, they can be a valuable tool for customer retention, data collection, and driving higher sales. The decision to implement such a program should be carefully considered, weighing the potential benefits against the costs. If you can design a program that offers meaningful rewards and does not break the bank, it could be a key differentiator in a very saturated, competitive marketplace.
This article was written by Kellie Struth and originally published in the April/May issue of Convenience and Impulse Retailing magazine.
To stay up to date on the latest industry headlines, sign up to the C&I e-newsletter.